O’Donnell Roofing has worked on enough older homes across the Main Line to know something most homeowners sense but rarely say out loud. The character of an older home is often its greatest asset — and one of the easiest things to accidentally renovate away.

Whether it’s the stone exterior, a slate roof, or copper accents, these details give an older home its personality. So does the way the house sits on its property. The challenge isn’t finding ways to make it look different. It’s finding ways to make it look like the best version of itself.

Start With What You Already Love

Before choosing a new roof color or scrolling through siding samples, the most useful first step is identifying what already works. Is it the combination of stone and cedar? The copper accents? The shape of the roof? The original windows?

Those details are the starting point. Instead of asking “What would make my house look completely different?” The better question is: “What would make the things I already love stand out?”

This approach matters especially with older homes, where replacing one element can shift the entire look. A roof, for example, accounts for a surprisingly large portion of what’s visible from the street. Choosing a color or material that complements existing stone, brick, or siding can make a renovation feel intentional rather than out of place.

Look at the Whole Picture Before Making the First Change

One of the most common mistakes in exterior renovation is choosing each element in isolation. A roof color might look beautiful on its own. So might a new siding color. But how will they look together alongside the existing stone, brick, trim, windows, and front door?

Many homeowners tackle exterior projects over several years, and that’s a perfectly reasonable approach. However, it helps to think about the bigger picture before making the first change. That way, each decision moves toward a cohesive result rather than away from one.

See It Before You Commit

One of the most useful developments in renovation planning is the availability of visualization tools. They let homeowners see changes before committing. Tools like HOVER and newer AI-powered platforms allow homeowners to upload a photo of their home and experiment with different exterior materials, colors, and styles.

Pinterest and Houzz can be helpful for gathering inspiration. But there’s an important distinction between finding a beautiful home online and figuring out what will look right on a specific house. A better approach is to collect examples that feel right, then look for common themes. Are the choices consistently drawn toward warmer colors? Natural materials? Classic combinations? Once those preferences are clear, it becomes easier to narrow down choices that make sense for the home’s architecture.

“With an older home, you want to be thoughtful about any changes you make. Visualization tools give homeowners the opportunity to see how different materials and colors work with the architecture of their actual home before they commit. It can help you find that balance between giving the house a fresh look and keeping the character that made you love it in the first place.”

— Kevin O’Donnell, Owner & CEO, O’Donnell Roofing Co. 

Know What to Keep and What to Refresh

Renovating doesn’t always mean replacing everything. In fact, some of the most beautiful older homes are ones where traditional elements have been thoughtfully maintained. Not swapped out entirely.

Natural slate, cedar, and copper can often be repaired or restored depending on their condition. In other cases, replacement is the better long-term choice. The important thing is to evaluate the home as a whole before deciding what needs to go.

When a roof is nearing the end of its life, that doesn’t necessarily mean giving up the look homeowners love. Today, materials like DaVinci synthetic slate and cedar-inspired products offer modern durability while maintaining a traditional appearance. That makes it possible to preserve the character of an older home even while updating its performance. O’Donnell Roofing’s full range of exterior services covers everything from roofing and siding to gutters, windows, and solar.

“We had been looking for a slate roof specialist for quite some time to replace our roofer who retired. My wife and I were immediately impressed by O’Donnell’s knowledge of the intricacies of repairing a slate roof. Throughout the process, Chuck gave us detailed updates of what he was doing and why. He had expert level knowledge of slate roofs and was polite, congenial, and professional. Best of all, the very fair price that was estimated was the price that we paid. My wife and I were delighted with O’Donnell and are very grateful to have finally found our “Slate Roof Caretaker”.

– Christopher M., Bryn Mawr, PA

Think Timeless First, Trendy Second

It’s easy to fall in love with a design trend. However, what’s popular today may not feel as right a few years from now, especially in a home with a strong architectural style.

That doesn’t mean avoiding trends altogether. Instead, the goal is to find ways to incorporate current design ideas without letting them overpower the character of the house. A fresh exterior color, updated lighting, or a new front door can give an older home a completely different feel without changing its personality. Similarly, replacing an aging roof or siding with a complementary material can make an entire house feel refreshed without making it look like new construction.

Work With Someone Who Understands the Home

A contractor should be able to do more than list available materials. They should be able to look at a home and understand why certain choices work and why others might not.

Older homes often have details not found in newer construction, and preserving those details requires experience and attention to the full exterior picture. Additionally, older homes tend to present more complex issues during renovation that can cause significant problems if not handled correctly from the start.

The right questions to ask any contractor are: What can be repaired rather than replaced? What materials would complement the existing architecture? Are there ways to improve the home’s performance without changing its appearance? A contractor who is willing to talk through those decisions and offer options rather than simply recommending the easiest replacement is one worth trusting with an older home.

For homeowners still doing their research, client reviews offer a candid look at what working with O’Donnell Roofing is really like. When ready to move forward, the team is easy to reach directly.

Make It Look Like Your Home, Only Better

The best exterior renovations don’t erase a home’s history. They showcase it. Whether the project involves replacing a roof, updating siding, or simply refreshing a front entry, the goal is to make thoughtful changes that enhance a home’s appearance while respecting what makes it special.

For Main Line and surrounding-area homeowners ready to start that conversation, O’Donnell Roofing brings the experience and attention to detail that older homes deserve. A thoughtful renovation can give a home a fresh look while keeping the character and charm that made it worth loving in the first place.

---

Photos courtesy of O’Donnell Roofing, as seen in the Home Improvement Guide.

O’Donnell Roofing’s story supports the Main Line Parent Community. Collaborate with us.